The
"Feeding of the Multitudes" is one of the most widely known
and beloved of Jesus' miracles. It's the only miracle story found in
all four Gospels. That fact, it seems to me, tells us in no
uncertain terms that it is God’s Will that the hungry be fed.
Mark
tells us the story in order to point to Jesus' deep compassion. John
is telling us the story in order to point to Jesus himself. John
calls the story "A Sign". It is for him, a mighty act of
God that points to Jesus' true identity, as the Holy One who comes
among us from the God of Israel.
But
if we stop and think about it, the “Feeding of the Multitudes” is
not only a "Sign", not only an example of Divine
compassion, not only a miracle story. It is also a tale of faith--
and a paradigm for our times.
Jesus
and the disciples and the women had gone out into the wilderness for
some time apart-- a retreat. Instead, they found themselves
surrounded by a huge crowd. Jesus guts had been twisted with
compassion and instead of resting he' d spent the day teaching them,
preaching to them, healing the sick they brought to Him. And, then at
the end of the day, yet another issue arose. Jesus brought it up
himself-- to test them, John tells us.
"So,
guys, anybody got any ideas where around here we can go to buy enough
bread for all these people?"
The
whole day had been after all, a spontaneous happening. There'd been
no Planning Committee, no Arrangements Committee, to plan and set up
a buffet. There was no United Methodist Women's circle around to
throw a potluck. There were no handy caterers nearby, or apparently
had any street vendors followed them into the wilderness with
pushcarts peddling hot dogs and Pepsis.
"How
are we going to feed them?"
Jesus asks-- with his tongue planted in cheek. Philip, who
apparently has a bit of bean counter in him, answers
"With
all due respect Master, I'm afraid you're putting the cart before the
horse here. We don't have enough money to buy bread for all these
people."
Probably
Philip was getting ready to suggest that they pass the hat around in
order to scrounge up enough money to buy food. (Philip apparently
even hadn't gotten around to figuring out where they were going to
buy food out there in the wilderness.)
But
Andrew had an idea. He turned around to the crowd and yelled out,
"Hey!
Anybody out there got any food?" And suddenly that huge,
noisy crowd-- all those thousands of men, women and children-- must
have gotten very, very quiet. They must have all looked around at
one another in nervous silence. Nobody had the nerve
It would seem to me that there would have had to be some food out
there in such a large crowd. Some of them must have had enough
foresight to bring a picnic basket along. But nobody ranted to admit
it. No one wanted to start sharing what he or she had, because they
all knew. There would not be enough to go around.
Nobody was willing to be the first one to admit that they even had a
crust of bread or a scrap of meat. They were afraid, because they
were sure that even if everyone who had some food contributed, there
still wouldn't be enough to go around. All those hungry people would
eat the food they'd brought for themselves, and they'd end up with
nothing-- or at best, not enough.
It's
at this point that the hero of the story shows up. No, it's not
Jesus, nor Andrew, nor Philip, nor any one of the Disciples. The hero
is not one of the women either. The real hero of the day was just a
young boy. He'd been watching Jesus all along-probably just standing
there with his mouth open. Maybe he had a front tooth or two missing,
a runny nose, dirty face, bare feet, and was dressed in a
hand-me-down patched tunic.
When
he heard Andrew’s request, the kid must have felt under his tunic
and found the lunch his mom had packed for him that day that he’d
likely forgotten to eat. And finding it, the boy didn’t hesitate.
“Hey
mister! Over here. I got somethin’.” And he held out five barley
tortillas and a couple of sardines. And the people nearby who saw him
probably smiled. Likely even the disciples found it amusing. But
Jesus didn’t laugh at the unhesitating generosity of a child. He
took that small boy and his willingness to share with ultimate
seriousness.
“Bring
them over here, son.”
And
Jesus took the bread and the fish, and had the disciples tell
everybody to sit down on the ground. Finally everybody was sitting
down except for Jesus. And of course that one small boy-standing
there beside him—his eyes full of wonder and his hand still
outstretched, offering Jesus his lunch of bread and fish.
John
tells us that Jesus took the five loaves and the two little fish and
blessed them. Then he handed them to the Twelve and told them,
“Divide
these among the people.”
Knowing there wouldn’t be enough to go around, the Disciples
probably looked at Jesus wondering if he’d gone crazy.
“Divide
what? What are five barley loaves and two small fish among so many
people?” But Jesus told them to just go ahead and do it.
So
they started tearing apart the fish, and breaking the bread in two,
and tearing apart the fish, and breaking the bread, and tearing apart
the fish, and breaking the bread, and tearing apart the fish, and
breaking the bread, and tearing apart the fish, and breaking the
bread, and tearing apart the fish…until, until somehow or other,
there was
enough to go around! Everybody got to eat their fill, and there was
still food left!
There
was in fact so much food that after lunch, the disciples went around
and collected the left-overs. John tells us there were twelve baskets
full. And I’m sure, given who Jesus was, the kid who was willing to
share his lunch got at least a couple of baskets of those left-overs
to take home to his mom.
So
what happened? Maybe that small boy’s open-handed generosity shamed
those adults who were hoarding some food of their own to step up to
the plate and share. Maybe on the other hand, Jesus actually made
more bread and fish materialize. Or maybe both those things happened
together. Maybe the people started sharing, and in response the bread
and the fish were multiplied—the human and the Divine working in
concert to feed God’s hungry sons and daughters. (Personally, I
kind of like that last possibly best, myself.)
But
I want to suggest that it doesn’t really matter which of those
three explanations you choose to believe. If you and I try to dwell
on, or try too hard to explain what happened, we’ll miss the sheer
extravagance. We’ll miss the overflowing, unexpected, unmerited,
wondrous grace that the story conveys.
Five
thousand fed. Not just a dab of fish paste on a cracker like you’d
get as a sample at Jewel’s. Not just a flimsy cardboard box from
the caterer containing an ounce of cream cheese, half a bagel, and an
apple. But five thousand full meals. Five thousand people fed and
satisfied—everybody’s belly filled and still twelve baskets
filled with left-overs. Give the reality of human nature, whatever
happened was still a genuine, dyed in the wool, honest to goodness
miracle!
I
don’t want to ignore John’s original intent in telling this
story as one of the signs of Christ’s divinity. That’s a crucial
theological understanding. But in our day and age, in this world of
ours, there’s another crucial lesson in the story—and in it’s
own way, it’s just as serious a lesson as the theological one.
I
hardly need to tell you that you and I are living in a world of
diminishing resources and rising expectations. We have famines today
in countries you and I never heard of a few years ago—countries
that didn’t even exist a few years ago.
And
since the last Great Depression, our nation’s government—under
Republicans and Democrats alike, has been paying some farmers not to
farm some of their fields. And for some reason or the other, proposed
legislation that would address that is irrevocably tied to
legislation that would cut the funds for our Food Stamp program.
And
of course, the deadly irony is that we have now—and have had for
decades—the agricultural technology and expertise to produce enough
food so that no one in this country—or in any country in the
world—needs to starve. The capabilities are there. Only one thing
stands in the way of the whole world being fed—politics.
We
live in a world where hunger has become a political tool. There are
countries where international food aid is withheld or distributed by
local governments in order to enhance their control over their own
population. There are food producing countries—such as our own—that
shamefully use food aid as a political lever, distributing it to
other lands solely on the basis of their government’s cooperation
with the political aims of our own.
In
the ancient and medieval world, it was considered acceptable to
conquer castles and walled cities by “laying siege” to them—which
is to say “starving them out.” Today, we live in a world where
hunger has become more than simply a weapon. In a very real sense
hunger has become the ultimate weapon of mass destruction.
There
are countries where famine is actually created by warring factions as
a tool of war waged on civilian populations. There are countries
where famine is purposefully being used as a tool of “ethnic
cleansing”—which is just another way of just saying genocide.
I’m
not sure I can think of a greater evil than to callously use human
hunger in that way. It’s certainly a horrible sin that calls out
for a strong and strident witness by Christians. The time has come
for those of us who call ourselves by His name what the Jesus who
commanded “Feed my sheep”
would do. The time has come for us to take a stand.
The
time has come for Christians to pressure our leaders of both parties
to change this sinful situation. The time has come for us to make
hunger an election issue. The time has come for us to ask candidates
questions around the politics of world hunger when they come before
us seeking our votes. The time has come for us to inform ourselves,
and write letters, and support organizations that attempt to address
the problem of hunger—both immediate and long-term. The time has
come for believers to look once more to the compassionate One who fed
5,000 in a single afternoon.
In
Jesus’ time, hunger—need—resulted from scarcity. There truly
was not enough bread, not enough resources, not enough energy
production, not enough wealth to go around. In much of the world
today that would still seem to be the case. But overall—for most of
the world it isn’t shortage, it’s surplus—it’s waste, it’s
human greed. We convince ourselves that there’s not enough to go
around , we look at those measly five barley tortillas and two
sardines and say to ourselves,
“What
are they among so many?” We don’t really believe in the
extravagance of our God. If there’s gonna be only five slices of
bread we figure we might as well have them. If there’s gonna be
only so many barrels of oil, we should get it. If there’s gonna be
limited resources, we’ll be the ones to use them.
We
see a need or a possibility that will bring benefit, but will require
resources. We know we ought
to do something. We can actually visualize something that might
make a difference. But
then, Philip the bean counter kicks in.
“How
are we gonna balance the budget if we do that?” We don’t really
believe—or we don’t want
to believe in the extravagant grace of God. I see that attitude on
the floor of Annual Conference every year. I’ve seen that attitude
in every one of the churches I’ve pastured. I’ve known that
attitude in my own heart, in my own home. “Tighten our belts. Don’t
spend money we don’t have. What’s the bottom line? What are so
few among so many?”
Don’t
mistake me. I know that budgets are crucial. Families need budgets,
businesses need budgets, churches need budgets. And every single time
I’ve heard some faithful believer say “Don’t worry. The Lord
will provide” a little tiny voice in the back of my mind has
replied “Yeah, but the Lord helps those who help themselves.”
Because
sometimes we, as individual believers are called to set our own fears
and hesitations aside. Sometimes we’re called to stop saying the
Lord helps those who help themselves. Rather, we’re invited at
times that those who are willing to help themselves to hope, to risk,
to reach out in compassion, to give without worrying about bottom
lines, to share without having to stop and consult the budget or
count the cost, all in His name—will indeed find that their Lord
will help them. They will discover the benefits of giving—both
spiritual and material benefits will far out weigh the costs.
To
their astonishment they will find that there will
indeed be enough to go
around—in surprising ways and yielding joyous possibilities the
bottom line could never imagined. And sometimes the people of God
are just called to set the bottom line aside and leap forward in
faith, doing their best as they discern it, to accomplish what
they’ve been called to do, and trust that there will be enough to
go around, that the God whose compassionate hand opens and provides
for the planet will provide. Sometimes a congregation is called to
believe that God will not allow a congregation whose heart and hands
are genuinely engaged in mission to die.
Jesus
told us that those who give in faith will receive back in abundance.
That’s
awfully hard for many of us to believe—much less live out. But all
around us are the cries of need. Every day it seems, you and I are
challenged to believe and share. But we fear that we’ll lose in the
giving, that at some point they’ll be nothing left to give, nothing
left for us because there isn’t enough to go around.
We
don’t really believe—or we don’t want
to believe in the extravagant grace of God. At such moments we would
do well to remember a small boy who was unhesitatingly willing to
share his lunch with thousands—without checking a budget or looking
at the bottom line or wondering if there’d be enough to go around.
That boy had no reason to believe he’d end up with anything to eat
that day—and yet he still gave. And instead, he went home with so
much more than he’d had in the first place. Given to him because
he’d been willing to offer all he had.